Interleaving in Pacemaker clones

Posted on Sun 26 February 2012 in hints-and-kinks • 2 min read

Ever wonder what meta interleave really means in a Pacemaker clone definition? We'll explain.

The interleave meta attribute is only valid on Pacemaker clone definitions – and their extended version of sorts, master/slave sets. It's not available on primitives and groups. Clones are often used in configurations involving cluster filesystems, such as GFS2 (here's an example).

Consider the following example (primitive definitions omitted to keep this short):

clone cl_foo p_foo meta interleave=false
clone cl_bar p_bar meta interleave=false
order o_foo_before_bar inf: cl_foo cl_bar

What this means is for the order constraint to be fulfilled, all instances of cl_foo must start before any instance of cl_bar can. Often, that's not what you want.

In contrast, consider this:

clone cl_foo p_foo meta interleave=true
clone cl_bar p_bar meta interleave=true
order o_foo_before_bar inf: cl_foo cl_bar

Here, for each node, as soon as the local instance of cl_foo has started, the corresponding local instance of cl_bar can, too. This is what's usually desired – when in doubt, allow interleaving.

One thing that often throws people is that interleaving only works when Pacemaker is configured to run the same number of instances of two clones on the same node. Thus,

clone cl_foo p_foo\
  meta interleave=true \
    globally-unique=true clone-node-max=2
clone cl_bar p_bar meta interleave=false
order o_foo_before_bar inf: cl_foo cl_bar

... won't work, as Pacemaker is allowed to run 2 instances of cl_foo on the same node, but only one of cl_bar (the default for clone-node-max is 1).

Also, globally-unique=true is a requirement for any clone-node-max>1 – which means that interleaving between a globally-unique and a not globally-unique clone is also not supported.

This article originally appeared on the website (now defunct).